|
The offending pile |
It’s the end of term, and even though I’ve been on leave, I’ve
stuck to my usual start-of-summer-vacation ritual and spent a day tidying my
office. This was in fact particularly necessary this year, because there have
been piles of notes (on secondary reading for the book) building up in corners
of the room, on tables, under chairs for some time now. As I move gradually
from a writing-up to an editing phase, it’s high time to get a handle on all this.
Once I'd retrieved all the unfiled notes and put them into
one big pile, that pile was alarmingly large. I had no idea that I’d read this
much about the Reformation and the late medieval church, all over Europe, in
the past few years. It was a nice surprise to see that I’d done much more work
that I’d realised, and a less pleasant discovery to find how little of this I
could remember reading, or knowing.
When I wrote my first book, the chapters were thematically
quite distinct (a chapter on art history, on diplomacy, on high politics), so
the notes from my secondary meeting were easy to keep on top off – you just
filed them according to which chapter they were relevant to. In Elusive Church, however, virtually
everything I’ve read contains ideas, or snippets of information, which are relevant
to two or more chapters, as well as the central argument set out in the
introduction. We solemnly tell our Freshers, in their first week, that keeping
your notes in good order is imperative. I’ve not done such a good job of that –
but writing a book is an organic process, even if the line between materials
naturally coalescing, and total chaos, is a fine one. And, at the end of the
day, I’m not sure there is any filing system which in itself solves the basic
problem – that it’s just very hard for one individual to keep in their head, at
any one time, the information from scores of monographs, not to mention
hundreds upon hundreds of sources. In that sense, pulling together a first full draft of this book is
reminding me more and more of revising for Finals – testing just how much
historical information, and argument, you can upload into your brain at once.